Dissent · Tue, Sep 22, 2026

One stock a day where insiders, the crowd, the headlines and our model disagree. We show where each stands and, at the 4:00 PM ET close, mark who was right from the price when the card was made. Today’s card

CMI: insiders are selling while the crowd is bullish

Four voices, one question: does CMI close above or below $523.44, its price when this card was made?

Cummins Inc.. #1 of our 3 picks today, and the one where the voices split widest.

$523.44 at 1:20 PM ET, when this card was made (already -2.12% on the day).

Leans up

  • Retail crowd · Up

    Bullish: 100% of 7 StockTwits posts with a bull or bear tag today.

  • Headlines · Up

    Positive: 92.9% of 16 headlines scored in the last 7 days.

  • Our model · Up

    Bullish: 83 out of 100 on our model (analyst ratings + social sentiment).

Leans down

  • Insiders & Congress · Down

    Selling: 0 buys, 1 sell in insider and Congress filings from the last 45 days. Insider sells can include scheduled plan sales.

CMI closed at $526.13, up 0.51% from $523.44 when the card was made. The up side was right: the crowd, the headlines and our model. Wrong: the insiders.

Not financial advice. Only the move after the card was made counts: it is scored from its price at 1:20 PM ET to the close, not on the whole day.

Not financial advice. The sources disagree on purpose; nothing here is a buy or sell signal.